All I really objected to was the leap from me not particularly minding to the fact that Quidditch scoring makes no sense to “. . . the best way to put it is that if Kit were to write SF, she would not write hard SF.” What the one has to do with the other seems to me to be up there with what my last name has to do with my husband’s for insurance purposes.
I will grant you that I’m not wildly *inclined* to write hard SF, but then, neither is anybody else in this . . . discussion.
Read Image’s post for a non-vitriolic explanation of what I’m talking about. Or don’t. Don’t is probably better for your sanity.